We study the interplay of optimal exante macroprudential and expost monetary or fiscal stimulus measures to respond to systemic financial crises in a tractable. The interaction between capital requirements and monetary policy. Macroprudential regulation versus mopping up after the crash olivier jeanne, anton korinek. Macroprudential meaning in the cambridge english dictionary. This column describes how the next generation of macroprudential stress tests aim to capture the endogenous nature of systemic risk caused by the interaction of all the institutions and markets making up the financial system. The dynamic pattern of treatment effects on students educational and labour market outcomes in adulthood. Imffsbbis elements of effective macroprudential policies. Corporate finance, economic fluctuations and growth, international finance and macroeconomics. Macroprudential stress tests vox, cepr policy portal. Macroprudential regulation versus mopping up after the crash teachers pay for performance in the longrun. The first required element of macroprudential oversight is a system for monitoring evolving risks to financial stability. A framework for macroprudential regulation that defines systemic risk and macroprudential policy, describes macroprudential tools, and surveys the effectiveness of existing macroprudential regulation. Some have argued in favor of macroprudential regulation to mitigate crisis risk exante, whereas others propose that.
After the end of the 2000 years of the financial crisis, there is a growing consensus among policymakers and economic researchers about the need to reorient the regulatory framework in future. Filmed at niesrs annual finance conference financial regulation are we reaching an efficient outcome. Charles goodhart on macroprudential regulation youtube. These reports draw to a large extent on notifications made by. In late 2017, bitcoin was in the spotlight for its extraordinary return. Optimal macroprudential policy resolves the time consistency problems associated with stimulus measures. Mar 22, 2016 filmed at niesrs annual finance conference financial regulation are we reaching an efficient outcome. Macroprudential regulation is an approach to financial regulation aimed to mitigate risks to the financial system as a whole. The guide also analyses the available range of macroprudential policy instruments, the risks or stresses that they can address and how these can be deployed. Systemic risk, or more precisely the relatively new public policy field of financial systemic risk management macroprudential regulation, has a distinctive emerging political economy. Jeanne and korinek 20 summarizes relevant literature and uses a stylized but general ramsey setup to show that the optimal policy mix consists of a combination of.
It is optimal for policymakers to use a mix of exante prudential measures and expost stimulus measures in response to financial crises risk. The failure of macroprudential regulation global financial news. Federal reserve board implementing a macroprudential. Macroprudential regulation council on economic policies. The notion of a macroprudential approach is not entirely new crockett, 2000. Just as a microprudential approach to regulation has come to emphasize building up capital because it makes the individual firm better able to absorb losses from any source, including unpredictable ones, so an appropriately refocused set of macroprudential capital requirements can help make the financial system better able to withstand shocks. Macroprudential regulation versus mopping up after. But it was only after the global financial crisis that policymakers fully came to appreciate the likelihood and costs of a systemic disruption in modern financial markets and the need to keep systemic risk in check. Olivier jeanne, johns hopkins university and anton korinek, university of. A method of economic analysis that evaluates the health, soundness and vulnerabilities of a financial system. However, as noted by clement 2010, the origin of the term macroprudential can be traced back to the late 70s. This paper compares exante policy measures such as macroprudential.
E44,g18,h23 abstract we study the interplay of optimal exante macroprudential and expost monetary or fiscal stimulus. Macroprudential regulation versus mopping up after the crash olivier jeanne anton korinek johns hopkins university, nber and cepr january 2016 abstract we study the interplay of optimal exante macroprudential and expost monetary or scal stimulus measures to respond to systemic nancial crises in a tractable model of re sales. Macroprudential regulation versus mopping up after the crash olivier jeanne johns hopkins university anton korinek university of maryland october 2012 abstract this paper compares exante policy measures such as macroprudential restrictions on leverage and expost policy interventions such as bailouts to. Part of the international economic association series book series iea. After the end of the 2000 years of the financial crisis, there is a growing consensus among policymakers and economic researchers about the. Macroprudential regulation versus mopping up after the crash olivier jeanne and anton korinek nber working paper no. The overall efficiency of these tools, however, is still uncertain. Tarullot september 20, 20, yale law school conference on challenges in global financial services, new haven, connecticut real world crises have a way of shaking up the intellectual foundations of policy disciplines. Could macroprudential regulation help prevent financial. The world economic forum is an independent international organization committed to improving the state of the world by engaging business, political, academic and other leaders of society to shape global, regional and industry agendas. We study the interplay of optimal exante macroprudential and expost monetary or fiscal stimulus measures to respond to systemic financial. It is an update and a further development of the reports that the esrb has been publishing since 2015. All through, the guide also flags the challenges that the authorities are likely to encounter while establishing and operating macroprudential policy framework and components.
Section 7 covers coordination of macroprudential policy with monetary policy, as well as governance issues. Spains use of dynamic provisioning, an accounting technique. Macroeconomics of imperfect capital markets, international finance, public finance, inequality. Macroprudential policies caps on loan to value ratios, limits on credit growth and. The recent financial crisis has shattered all standard approaches to banking regulation. Oct 11, 2012 third, the build up to the recent crisis resulted more from a microprudential failure than a macroprudential one. We study the interplay of optimal exante macroprudential and expost monetary or fiscal stimulus measures to respond to systemic financial crises in a. First, central banks engaged in strong expansionary monetary policy, using new. Pdf macroprudential regulation versus mopping up after. Macroprudential analysis looks at the health of the. The two policies are substitutes for each other since they address the same goal from different angles, implying that in general, macroprudential policy is used more when liquidity policies are restricted and vice versa. Macroprudential regulation versus mopping up after the crash, nber working papers 18675, national bureau of economic research, inc. One of the major concerns at this time in the financial regulatory.
A macroprudential approach to financial regulation by samuel g. With this in mind, on 2627 october 2015 the central bank of. The short answer to the riddle of growth vs interest rates posed by jim glassman is excessive regulation. Monetary policy, macroprudential regulation and inequality. A macroprudential approach to financial regulation american. What macroprudential regulation is, and why it matters. The old lean versus clean debate is resolved once again now in favor of leaning. Abstract a growing literature has investigated optimal policy responses to the externalities that arise from financial crises. Systemic risk, crises, and macroprudential regulation the. Published in volume 25, issue 1, pages 328 of journal of economic perspectives, winter 2011, abstract. Implementing the macroprudential approach in the united states let me be more concrete and talk about the implementation of the macroprudential approach in the context of the evolving u.
Macroprudential regulation versus mopping up after the crash olivier jeanne anton korinek jhu, nber and cepr uva, darden and nber june 2019 abstract how should macroprudential policy be designed when policymakers also have access to liquidity provision tools to manage crises. Macroprudential regulation versus mopping up after the crash by o. The prefix macro indicates that the policies or actions relate to the whole or significant parts of the financial system rather than individual financial institutions. Inequality, interest rates, macroprudential regulation the 2008 global financial crisis profoundly changed the role of central banks in the economy. With this in mind, on 2627 october 2015 the central bank of the republic. Global banking and the conduct of macroprudential policy in a. Macroprudential regulation is the approach to financial regulation that aims to mitigate risk to the financial system as a whole or systemic risk. The move from primarily micro to combined micro and macroprudential financeregulatory regimes is surely to be welcomed, for reasons that this author and others have offered in earlier articles. Jeanne, olivier and anton korinek, macroprudential regulation versus mopping up after the crash, nber working paper no. Korinek 20 macroprudential regulation versus mopping up after the crash. Macroprudential regulation versus mopping up after the crash, 20 meeting papers 405, society for economic dynamics. Studies also highlight the potential impact of inequality on credit market soundness and thus on the design of optimal macroprudential regulation.
However, macroprudential regulation is still very much work in progress. Third, the buildup to the recent crisis resulted more from a microprudential failure than a macroprudential one. Macroprudential regulation versus mopping up after the crash pecuniary externalities and secondbest interventions olivier jeanne and anton korinek jhu and umd conference on incorporating financial stability into in. The easing in us mortgage lending standards, the growing reliance on shortterm wholesale funding, the low risk weights applied to complex and highly leveraged structured securities were all things that an avowedly microprudential. The effectiveness of macroprudential tools, including empirical analysis, is dealt with in section 6. Sep 30, 2014 economist jordi gali analyses the causes and consequences of the current crisis from a macroeconomic perspective in the inaugural lecture for the academic ye. Macroprudential regulation versus mopping up after the crash pdf nber. On the empirics of reserve requirements and economic growth. An overview of macroprudential policy tools imf elibrary. Macroprudential regulation versus mopping up after the crash, nber. Current stress testing of banks is focused on the resiliency of individual banks to exogenous shocks. However, if macroprudential policy is suboptimal, for example because of circumvention, only monetary stimulus should be used, and it is desirable to commit to smaller stimulus. The term macroprudential has become a popular term after the recent financial crisis see figure 1. Macroprudential regulation versus mopping up after the crash olivier jeanne anton korinek jhu, nber and cepr uva, darden and nber august 2019 abstract how should macroprudential policy be designed when policymakers also have access to liquidity provision tools to manage crises.
This implies that policymakers should both lean against the wind and mop up after the crash. Macroprudential regulation versus mopping up after the crash olivier jeanne johns hopkins university anton korinek university of maryland november 2011 abstract a growing literature has investigated optimal policy responses to the externalities that arise from nancial crises. Macroprudential regulation versus mopping up after the crash. Macroprudential regulation versus mopping up after the crash olivier jeanne johns hopkins university anton korinek university of maryland november 2011 abstract a growing literature has investigated optimal policy responses to the externalities that arise from. To consider bitcoin volatility, we look at 10day returns capital standards typically estimate market risk over a 10day period since 19 july 2010, when bloombergs bitcoin data start. Iin this paper, we offer a detailed vision for how a macroprudential regime n this paper, we offer a detailed vision for how a macroprudential regime. Bank branches and macroprudential policymaking in the eu 58 a. The ecbs responsibilities in the area of macroprudential policy stem from the single supervisory mechanism ssm regulation. Bianchi, javier and enrique mendoza, overborrowing, financial crisis, and macro. In this paper, we analyze borrowerbased limits and their impact on bank credit. The effects on inequality of macroprudential regulation e. The anatomy of the transmission of macroprudential policies lse. Advanced macroeconomic analysis ii columbia university. Macroprudential regulation, residential mortgage credit, house.
Regulators now recognize that banking regulation cannot be simply based on individual financial. In the aftermath of the late2000s financial crisis, there is a growing consensus among policymakers and economic researchers about the need to reorient the regulatory framework towards a macroprudential perspective. This paper compares exante policy measures such as macroprudential regulation and expost policy interventions such as bailouts to respond to financial crises in models of financial. Macroprudential regulation versus mopping up after the. Incorporated as a notforprofit foundation in 1971, and headquartered in geneva, switzerland, the forum is tied to no political, partisan or national interests.
439 312 1269 570 2 1163 98 918 889 1131 178 322 1090 1283 256 1207 560 882 291 1346 1258 50 467 443 1076 426 1042 1152 1258 1076 896 770 915 415 1058